Release Date: March 26, 1985Members: Tom Petty (vocals, guitar); Mike Campbell (guitar); Benmont Tench (piano, organ); Howie Epstein (bass); Stan Lynch (drums)
Produced by Jimmy Iovine
Side One: Rebels; It Ain't Nothin' To Me; Don't Come Around Here No More; Southern Accents
Side Two: Make it Better (Forget About Me); Spike; Dogs on the Run; Mary's New Car; The Best of Everything
Conceived as a concept album about the South, Tom Petty's most problematic LP Southern Accents was recorded during a stressful point in the band's career. Nevertheless, it was well received and produced a major hit with "Don't Come Around Here No More." During the tour in support of the record Petty used Confederate iconography during concerts, as modern critics have pointed out the Neo-Confederate undertones running through the record and subsequent tour.
"Rebels" opens the album with a hardscrabble tale of tough love and generational resentments, specifically referencing Sherman's March and the damaged pride of Southern white men, while remaining silent on the debt owed to Black culture. Petty reframes these themes through the lens of '80s rock and roll with a catchy arrangement and impassioned vocal performance. Conflating rock and roll with rebellion appears trite these days and was even showing its age by the 1980s, the sentiment comes through but not without mawkishness.
"It Ain't Nothin" To Me" is a Dylanesque sermon of sorts with hints of a disco beat. The Alice in Wonderland themed music video for "Don't Come Around Here No More" was an MTV staple. Petty wrote the song with Dave Stewart, inspired by a wild L.A. party and an encounter with Stevie Nicks. The most sophisticated track by the band up to that point, the production and vocals are inspired. "Southern Accents" could be accused of trafficking in 'Lost Cause" mythology of the white man being the only one who truly understands freedom (or the perspective of poor whites exploited by the economic system), Petty ends the songs with:
I got my own way of livin'
But everything gets done
With southern accent
Where I come from
The "Don't Tread on Me" sentiment comes off as more aggrieved than poetic, once again tonally out of synch with the song's intention.
"Make it Better (Forget About Me)" seeks to mend a relationship in a nod towards blue-eyed soul. "Spike" is a playful track about an eccentric character, I wonder if they debated whether this one belonged on the album. "Dogs on the Run" muses on life and desire, the mix of guitars and horns cancel each other out. "Mary's New Car" is exactly what the title promises and nothing less. Ending with 'The Best of Everything", Petty deals in iconography like Bruce Springsteen, a sad romance with a waitress (not that Bruce holds a monopoly on tragic diner romances).
To his credit, Petty later disavowed the strains of white supremacy on Southern Accents and implored his fans to not display the confederate flag. One can read an interview here with Michael Washburn who wrote the 33 1/3 book on the album and interrogated its ties to lost cause ideology.
Musically, Southern Accents is a band trying to escape from a creative stupor. Petty's frustration with the production led to him punching a wall and seriously injuring his hand. Whether one views the record as a failed experiment, a misguided reflection on southern culture and history, or a record at best hinting at creative breakthrough, it was anything but a disaster as the band continued to tour and make records in the decades to come.